Showing posts with label obesity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label obesity. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Improving Self Reported BMI

Many epidemiological studies measure adiposity (obesity) through the surrogate BMI via self reported measures of height and weight. As I have mentioned before, there are many problems with this. But how can we improve on this while maintaining our level of accuracy and not using a direct measure requiring a more intensive doctor visit?

Two ideas to use along with BMI:
1. Waist size - pant size for men, dress size for women
2. Bench press - probably more reasonable for men. Could use max (weight you can bench press once), or weight you can bench press ten times.

Monday, February 23, 2009

Measuring Fat by MRI

A striking image that won a National Geographic Picture of Year award. The images are full body MRI shots of two women: 5'6" 250 lbs on the left, 5'5" 120 lbs on the right.

Looks like there is a lot of alteration in most areas of the body except for brain and maybe the ankle area. I wonder if pictures like these could be used for the fight against obesity?

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Fat Asians

Obesity is a huge emerging problem that I talked about last month. The most common measurement is BMI, which is flawed in many ways. BMI or Body Mass Index measures your weight compared to your height. It does not take into account muscle or particularly kind of fat (healthly or non-healthly). Muscular men seem to be considered overweight (>25 kg/m^2) or obese (>30 kg/m^2) even appearing very fit and having very low % body fat.

Muscular men are not the only ones mischaracterized by this measure; a 2004 Paper from the Lancet suggests that Asians are at greater risk of obesity related diseases (cardiovascular disease, diabetes) at lower BMIs than Caucasians. Asians appear to have increased subcutaneous and upper body fat that is not captured by the BMIs. These fat measurements can be captured in other ways like body fat percentage....




a study in new york measured the following:
Body Fat % at BMI of 25 kg/m^2
Males: Whites: 19.2, Asians: 23.6
Females: Whites: 34.2 Asians: 36.8

Based on the these finding in others the WHO recommended (pdf) the following:

"For many Asian populations, additional trigger points for
public health action were identified as 23 kg/m2 or higher,
representing increased risk, and 27·5 kg/m2 or higher as
representing high risk. The suggested categories are as
follows: less than 18·5 kg/m2 underweight; 18·5–23 kg/m2
increasing but acceptable risk; 23–27·5 kg/m2 increased
risk; and 27·5 kg/m2 or higher high risk."
To summarize/oversimplify, an overweight Caucasian has a BMI over 25, while an overweight Asian has a BMI over 23. No worries my deceivingly chubby Asian friends, the WHO also mentions that the overweight cutoff varies by Asian population from 22-25. My suggestion for those of all races is to get your body fat percentage measured along with your waist/hip ratio - assuming you need more motivation to eat healthy and exercise (or if you just like numbers). Hopefully in the future the health community can improve on the BMI measure and use a less archaic measurement that is less misleading.

Friday, August 29, 2008

Obesity

-A recent study by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation reminded me of our obesity problem:
New Report: Adult Obesity Rates Rise in 37 States, Obesity Rates Now Exceed 25 Percent in More Than Half of States
"In 1991, no state had an obesity rate above 20 percent. In 1980, the national average of obese adults was 15 percent. Now, an estimated two-thirds of American adults are overweight or obese"

The CDC has some striking maps on the epidemic. Following them for the past twenty years can be very convincing that we have a serious problem on our hand.:



Video of the change in US Obesity from 1985-2007




BMI vs. Other Measures
-The most common measure of obesity - BMI (Body Mass Index - weight in kg/height in meters) is a bit flawed. It does not distinguish between muscle and fat. Those that are extremely buff are likely to be considered overweight or obese by this scale. Researchers also consider waist to hip ratios and body fat percentage when analyzing weight. However these two measure are much more difficult to gather on a population level.

Should one consider herself overweight or obese if their BMI is over 25 or 30? I think you should consider your body fat percentage (should be less than 15% for men, less than 25% for women) and waist to hip ratio before drawing that conclusion. That being said the data from all three of these measures show a very dramatic incline.

Genetic Link?
Adoption studies provide insight on if the problem is due to the environment or genetics. While seeing how quickly these inclines have increased, environment must have a rather important role on the subject. However adoption studies show that adoptees weight are more highly correlated to their biological parents weight than adoptive parents weight - giving argument that obesity can be considered somewhat genetic.

Another argument for the genetic cause of obesity is the country of nauru. Nauru is a pacific island that currently tops in obesity at 94.5% of their adult population. Their story is rather interesting. In World War 2 they were deported from their country by the Japanese to a small food lacking island in micronesia. During that time a considerable portion starved to death (approx one third). After returning back to their country, the survivors lifestyle changed after gaining wealth and becoming much more sedentary. This can be considered a human experiment for the genetic link to obesity. The survivors from micronesia were the ones who had a better propensity to store food, but also the ones who can become more obese.

Should insurance companies increase premiums for the obese?
Health insurance should consider obesity when determining rate, but instead of punishing those who are obese they should reward those who are being active. If people got rebates for losing weight, that would be a little extra motivation. However it is more difficult to discriminate when the problem is partially genetic.

Should the government subsidize healthier food so it can be bought by the poor?
While healthier food such as fruit, vegetables and fish are pretty expensive - I don't know if subsidizing them will attract too many more poor customers. Our income inequalities in this country are problematic to say the least, and there isn't any easy solution to this problem. My current thought is to tax foods with high percentage of trans and saturated fats, sort of like what is currently done with cigarettes.